• Home
  • About
    • About Woodsmall Law Group, PC.
    • Mark Woodsmall
    • Robert Johnston
    • Rebecca O'Malley
    • Justin Youngs
    • Max Goldman
    • Community Involvement
  • Our Services
    • Our Services
    • IEP
      • IEP
      • IEP Checklist
      • Preparing for an IEP
      • Extracurricular Activities and IEPs
      • Understanding Parts of IEP Document
      • IEP Conflicts
      • Requesting an IEP Case Review
      • School Discipline and IEP Protections
    • Filing For Due Process
    • 504 Plan
    • Private School Placement
    • Regional Center
    • IDEA
    • IFSP
    • Adult Programs and Transition
    • Mediation and Resolution Sessions
    • Los Angeles Unified School District Special Education Attorneys
  • Parent Resources
    • Parent Resources
    • When to Contact a Los Angeles Special Education Attorney?
    • High School Transition Planning
    • One to One Aides
    • Assistive Technology
    • California Self-Determination Programs
    • FERPA
    • Evaluations
    • Parent Access
    • IDEA Divorced Parent
    • In-Home Support Services
    • IEP, Records, and Due Process Deadlines
    • 2E Student Education
    • School Advocacy Toolkit
    • Seizure Action Plans
    • Parent Support Groups
    • Special Education Landmark Cases
    • Communicating with Your Legislator
    • College Life: Obtaining Disability Services
    • When High School Graduation Results in Termination of Services
    • Report Writing for Professionals
    • Webinars
  • Helpful Information
    • Helpful Information
    • Questions and Answers
    • Research Based Inventions
    • Special Education In the News
    • What SB 277 Means
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
Articles

When Insurance Requirements Interfere with a Student’s Right to an Independent Educational Evaluation

By Woodsmall Law Group, PC. on November 5, 2026

A Growing Obstacle to Independent Evaluations

California decisions raise serious questions about school districts imposing sexual abuse and molestation insurance requirements on independent educational evaluators.

By Mark Woodsmall – Woodsmall Law Group, PC

Across California, independent educational evaluators are encountering an increasingly troubling obstacle: school districts requiring them to maintain specialized Sexual Abuse and Molestation (SAM) liability insurance before permitting them to conduct publicly funded Independent Educational Evaluations (IEEs).

These requirements may appear to be routine risk-management measures. However, in practice, they can create significant financial and administrative barriers for qualified psychologists, occupational therapists, speech-language pathologists, and other professionals who provide independent evaluations.

Many qualified evaluators maintain professional liability insurance but do not carry separate SAM coverage. Such coverage may be unduly expensive, difficult to obtain, or disproportionate to the evaluator’s professional activities.

When a district conditions approval of an independent evaluation on insurance requirements that are not equally applicable to its own assessors, an important legal question arises: Can a school district use its contracting requirements to restrict a parent’s federally protected right to an independent educational evaluation?

Two recent California administrative decisions provide substantial support for challenging this practice.

The IDEA Protects a Parent’s Right to an Independent Evaluation

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), parents who disagree with a school district’s evaluation are entitled to request an IEE at public expense.

Once an appropriate request is made, the district must, without unnecessary delay, either agree to fund the evaluation or initiate due process proceedings to defend its own assessment.

Federal law also places meaningful limitations on the criteria school districts may impose upon independent evaluators.

Under 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(e), the criteria governing publicly funded IEEs must be the same as those used by the district when conducting its own assessments, to the extent consistent with the parent’s right to an IEE. Outside the permitted criteria, districts may not impose additional conditions or timelines.

This protection serves an essential purpose. Independent evaluations are intended to provide an objective assessment of a student’s needs, particularly when parents question the adequacy of the district’s findings. The right becomes substantially less meaningful when otherwise qualified evaluators are excluded through requirements unrelated to their professional qualifications or their ability to conduct appropriate assessments.

Recent California Decisions Challenge Unduly Restrictive SAM Insurance Requirements

In two separate 2025 decisions involving Palo Alto Unified School District, California’s Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) addressed the application of SAM insurance requirements to independent evaluators.

OAH Case No. 2025030845 – July 11, 2025

In this proceeding, Palo Alto rejected the parents’ selected occupational therapy assessor because the evaluator did not satisfy the district’s SAM insurance requirement.

The evidence raised significant questions regarding whether the same insurance requirements applied to the district’s own employees and contracted assessors. The Administrative Law Judge also considered the district’s failure to pursue due process proceedings to defend its refusal to fund the evaluation. As part of the remedy, the judge ordered Palo Alto to suspend its SAM insurance requirement for the student’s occupational therapy IEE.

An important caveat: The ruling was expressly limited to that student’s evaluation, but it reflects an important principle: insurance requirements cannot simply be assumed permissible when they interfere with the exercise of federally protected IEE rights.

OAH Case No. 2025030847 – November 6, 2025

A subsequent decision involving Palo Alto examined similar insurance restrictions in even greater detail.

The district had imposed requirements that included $1 million per occurrence in sexual abuse and molestation coverage, along with other liability insurance provisions. Evidence established that these requirements excluded otherwise available independent assessors or increased the cost of obtaining their services. The Administrative Law Judge found that the district had not established that its insurance requirements were the same as those applied to its own assessors.

The requirements were also inconsistent with the parent’s right to obtain an independent evaluation and were not authorized by the applicable SELPA criteria.

The decision ordered that the independent evaluators need not comply with Palo Alto’s insurance criteria.

These decisions do not establish a categorical statewide prohibition on SAM insurance requirements. Nevertheless, they offer persuasive administrative authority for challenging requirements that are inconsistent with federal IEE protections.

A School District’s Liability Concerns Cannot Become a Barrier to Federal Rights

Woodsmall Law Group, PC recognizes the legitimate responsibility of school districts to protect students from abuse, misconduct, and other foreseeable risks.

Appropriate safeguards, including professional qualifications, background screening where legally required, supervision procedures, and reasonable insurance practices, can play important roles in student protection.

However, these responsibilities must be reconciled with the district’s independent obligations under the IDEA.

A school district cannot assume that its general authority to impose contractual safeguards allows it to add conditions to publicly funded IEEs that federal regulations do not permit.

The relevant inquiry is not simply whether SAM insurance serves a legitimate risk-management purpose. It is whether requiring that coverage from an independent evaluator complies with the specific limitations imposed by 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(e).

The district must also consider whether the requirement effectively deprives families of access to qualified independent professionals. This distinction is especially important where the district’s own assessment personnel are covered through different insurance arrangements or where the district cannot establish that comparable requirements apply to those personnel.

California Department of Education Guidance Reinforces These Protections

On March 11, 2021, the California Department of Education issued statewide guidance regarding Independent Educational Evaluations.

The Department emphasized that school districts may not impose additional conditions or timelines inconsistent with their own assessment criteria or that would deny students and parents their right to obtain publicly funded IEEs.

Although the guidance did not specifically address SAM insurance, its interpretation of the federal regulations reinforces the concerns presented by the Palo Alto decisions.

A district’s contracting practices must be evaluated against the parent’s substantive and procedural rights under federal special education law.

What Independent Evaluators and Families Should Do

When an independent evaluator is rejected because of a SAM insurance requirement, families and providers should request written clarification of the district’s legal and factual basis for imposing that condition.

Particularly important questions include:

  • Does the district impose the same insurance requirement upon its own employees and contracted evaluators?
  • Is the requirement contained in the district’s established IEE criteria, or was it added during contracting?
  • Does the requirement prevent otherwise qualified evaluators from conducting the assessment?
  • Has the district identified alternative qualified assessors who satisfy both its insurance requirements and its established IEE funding criteria?
  • Is the district willing to waive, modify, or otherwise resolve the insurance requirement so the evaluation can proceed without unnecessary delay?

Where a district cannot justify the restriction under the IDEA, families may have grounds to challenge its application.

Independent evaluators should also be mindful that contracting disputes can have direct consequences for students. A delayed assessment may postpone necessary educational planning, services, and interventions.

Protecting the Integrity of Independent Evaluations

Independent Educational Evaluations are not merely administrative services purchased by school districts. They are an essential component of the IDEA’s procedural safeguards, designed to ensure that parents have access to qualified independent professional opinions when questions arise about their child’s educational needs.

Reasonable student-safety protections and the right to independent evaluation are not mutually exclusive.

But school districts must not allow insurance provisions to become a mechanism for restricting access to independent expertise. The central principle is straightforward: School district risk-management policies must operate within the limits of federal special education law, not override them.

Families and evaluators confronted with insurance requirements that obstruct an independent assessment should carefully examine the district’s justification, its established IEE criteria, and whether comparable requirements apply to the district’s own evaluators.

The recent Palo Alto decisions offer an important framework for that analysis. Families or independent professionals encountering this difficulty should consider reading these decisions.

Legal Authorities:

  • Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1).
  • 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b), (e).
  • California Department of Education, Independent Educational Evaluations, March 11, 2021.
  • Parents on Behalf of Student v. Palo Alto Unified School District, OAH Case No. 2025030845 (July 11, 2025).
  • Parent on Behalf of Student v. Palo Alto Unified School District, OAH Case No. 2025030847 (November 6, 2025).

Mark Woodsmall and Woodsmall Law Group, PC

Mark Woodsmall is the founder of Woodsmall Law Group, PC, a Pasadena-based law firm focused exclusively on special education and disability-related legal matters. For more than 20 years, Mark has advocated for children with disabilities, helping families secure the educational services, accommodations, and resources their children need to succeed.

In addition to his legal practice, Mark has served as an Adjunct Professor at the USC Gould School of Law since 2006, teaching special education law. He has contributed to the development of future advocates through the Special Education Advocacy Training Project (SEAT) and held leadership positions with Autism Speaks. He also serves on the UCLA Center for Autism Research & Treatment Community Advisory Committee, reflecting his continued commitment to the autism community.

At Woodsmall Law Group PC, we represent families throughout Pasadena, the San Gabriel Valley, Los Angeles, and surrounding Southern California communities. We are committed to protecting the educational rights of children with disabilities and helping parents navigate complex special education disputes.

Speak With an Experienced Southern California Special Education Attorney

If your child’s school district requires independent educational evaluators to carry specialized Sexual Abuse and Molestation (SAM) liability insurance as a condition of conducting publicly funded Independent Educational Evaluations (IEEs), you may have legitimate questions about whether this requirement is permissible under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA).

Such restrictions may raise concerns about access to qualified evaluators and the procedural safeguards intended to protect your child’s educational rights.

Whether you are facing disputes over independent evaluations, your child’s Individualized Education Program (IEP), school placement, accommodations, or access to appropriate educational services, the Los Angeles special education lawyers at our firm can help you understand your rights and explore your options.

Call Woodsmall Law Group, PC at (626) 440-0028 for a free consultation. We can review your concerns, explain how special education laws may apply to your situation, and discuss steps you can take to protect your child’s educational opportunities.

Related Articles:

  • Head Start Protections for Children With Disabilities Are at Risk
  • Understanding the Special Education Rights of Twice-Exceptional Students: Woodsmall Law Group, PC. Secures a Watershed Decision
  • Woodsmall Law Group, PC. is honored to be published in TAP, The Autism Perspective Magazine.
  • Autism Speaks Publishes Woodsmall Law Group, PC.’s School Advocacy Toolkit

Posted in: Firm News

Categories

  • COVID-19
  • Firm News
  • IEP
  • Resources
  • Special Eduaction
  • Vaccinations

Recent Posts

  • When Insurance Requirements Interfere with a Student’s Right to an Independent Educational Evaluation
  • Head Start Protections for Children With Disabilities Are at Risk
  • Can a School District Limit an Independent Evaluator’s Classroom Observation to 20 Minutes?
  • The Importance of Social Emotional Learning in Special Education: What LA Parents Need to Know
  • What Qualifies a Student for an IEP in California Schools?
  • Main Website
  • Articles
  • RSS
  • Contact
  • Articles Sitemap
2076 Lincoln Ave, Pasadena, CA 91103

T 626 440-0028
F 626 440 0068

Pround Members of:

© 2026 Woodsmall Law Group, PC.